Third Circuit: Group Against Smog and Pollution v. Shenango Inc

Administrative law - citizen suit/environment

Statute's requirement that there not be a pre-existing diligent prosecution of rights under the statute in order to permit a citizen suit is a substantive requirement, not a jurisdictional bar to suit.

A final judgment resulting from a diligent prosecution does not, in itself, remove the bar to citizen suit.

Diligent enforcement of outcome acts as a per se bar to citizen suit.

http://www2.ca3.uscourts.gov/opinarch/152041p.pdf