Third Circuit: Laurence Kaplan v. Saint Peter's Healthcare System

ERISA, Religion -- statutory construction.

While a church agency can maintain an exempt plan, only a church can establish one.

Plain meaning.

Surplussage, Expressio unius..., Remedial statute, Statutory context.

Other statements by same sources in legislative record undermine indications to the contrary.

IRS ruling was not a rulemaking, so only accorded persuasive deference. (Christiansen, not Skidmore)

In subsequent lawmaking that seemed to legislate against the background of a contrary interpretation, Congress never evinced a detailed knowledge of the statutory scheme.

First Amendment not implicated, as churches themselves are free to set up plans.

http://www2.ca3.uscourts.gov/opinarch/151172p.pdf